notify has no support for smtplib local_host parameter

[panewman@…]

The constructor for an SMTP object in smtplib takes an optional 3rd parameter, 'local_hostname', otherwise it will execute the following line in smtplib.py:

addr = socket.gethostbyname(socket.gethostname())

which always fails on my system, because my hostname is not fully-qualified. I've only been able to successfully send mail using smtplib when I set the local_hostname parameter.

However, Notify.py, has no way of setting this:

def begin_send(self):
    self.server = smtplib.SMTP(self.smtp_server, self.smtp_port)

(only the first two parameters are used)

It should be possible to specify the third parameter of this constructor from trac.ini.

[Emmanuel Blot]

Did you try to add your local IP address in your '/etc/hosts' file?

[anonymous]

Actually it was outdated…

I wish I had looked there first. Thanks for the reminder!

[Emmanuel Blot]

Please close the bug as worksforme if the trouble is fixed on your computer.

[Matthew Good]

Since smtplib supports this as a parameter it would still be good to add. I've seen other people encounter the same issue.

[Emmanuel Blot]

Did the issue actually come from this missing parameter or from a faulty server setting?
There are a lot of parameters in the smtplib that we (hopefully) do not support.

I don't mind adding an extra parameter (although this means just another parameter to add to the documentation), but is this setting really required for sane environments? - just asking.

[Matthew Good]

Actually I think that previous problem I had seen related to IP resolution were with BaseHTTPServer, so maybe this isn't a common issue.

So, I'll go ahead and close this ticket. If someone has a reason this is still needed please reopen it.